In Episode 181 of The Fin Factor, Paul and Aaron are live from the SAP Center for the San Jose Sharks’ 2023 Draft Party. Joined by prospect expert Graham Montgomery, they provide live analysis as the franchise makes one of the most important selections in its history.
The Fourth Overall Pick: Will Smith
The centerpiece of the episode is the Sharks selecting Will Smith from the U.S. National Team Development Program (USNTDP) with the fourth overall pick.
- Elite Offensive Ceiling: Graham and the hosts describe Smith as a dynamic, “high-end” offensive talent with exceptional vision and playmaking ability.
- The “BC Connection”: The hosts discuss Smith’s commitment to Boston College, noting that his chemistry with fellow top prospects could be a major factor in his development.
- Draft Philosophy: The selection is viewed as General Manager Mike Grier choosing a “sure thing” offensive pillar over higher-risk options like Matvei Michkov.
The Matvei Michkov Debate
The episode features a deep dive into why the Sharks passed on Russian phenom Matvei Michkov, who was considered by some to be the second-best talent in the draft.
- Risk Factors: The group debates the “Michkov factor,” including concerns over his KHL contract status and the uncertainty of when he would arrive in North America.
- Character and Fit: While Graham acknowledges Michkov’s “superstar” potential, the hosts discuss whether Smith’s character and immediate availability better aligned with Grier’s vision for the team culture.
Goaltending and Late Round Strategy
Beyond the first round, the conversation turns toward the Sharks’ desperate need for a long term solution in goal.
- Evaluating the Pipeline: The hosts express concern over current goaltending weaknesses, specifically regarding size and technique.
- Drafting for Need: They discuss the strategy of trading up for goaltenders, citing historical examples like Jake Oettinger as a model the Sharks might consider to solidify the position.
The Atmosphere at SAP Center
Being live at the draft party, the hosts capture the energy of a fanbase looking for hope.
- Fan Engagement: Paul and Aaron interact with the crowd, noting that the selection of Will Smith was met with significant approval from the fans in attendance.
- The Rebuild Kickoff: The episode frames this draft as the official start of a new era, with Smith representing the first “elite” piece added to the team’s future core.
