In Episode 216, Paul and Aaron break down the start of NHL free agency, focusing on major veteran acquisitions and the changing philosophy of the Sharks front office.
The Sharks kicked off free agency with a splash, proving that General Manager Mike Grier is ready to spend to improve the roster. The hosts noted that this marks a departure from the previous regime, which often relied on trades and re-signings rather than high-end free agent additions.
Tyler Toffoli: A Landmark Signing
The biggest headline of the day was the signing of veteran winger Tyler Toffoli to a four-year, $24 million contract.
- A Record-Breaking Deal: Toffoli’s $6 million AAV is reportedly the largest contract the Sharks have ever handed out in free agency to a player not already on the team.
- The “Monterey” Connection: Paul and Aaron joked that Toffoli’s wife, a Monterey native, likely played a significant role in his decision to return to Northern California.
- Shoot-First Mentality: The hosts highlighted that Toffoli brings a much-needed “shooter” mentality to a team filled with playmakers, which should immediately improve the Sharks’ offense and power play.
- Veteran Pedigree: With over 500 career points and a Stanley Cup ring from his time with the Kings, Toffoli provides elite veteran leadership for the team’s young core.
Roster Management and the “Hertl” Comparison
The discussion of Toffoli’s age and contract length led to a comparison with former Shark Tomas Hertl.
- Durability Concerns: While both players are around the same age, the hosts argued that Toffoli’s game may age better than Hertl’s “rough and tumble” style, especially given Hertl’s history of knee injuries.
- Strategic Move: Signing Toffoli for four years was seen as a win, as many other teams were likely unwilling to offer that much term to a 32-year-old.
The Celebrini and Will Smith Impact
The hosts discussed how these veteran signings are designed to create a better environment for the team’s top prospects.
- Enticing the Top Pick: There was speculation that adding players like Toffoli could help convince Macklin Celebrini to sign and go pro rather than returning to college.
- Will Smith is Coming: With Will Smith already signed, the focus is now on surrounding him and potentially Celebrini with established NHLers who can take the pressure off the rookies.
Building Depth and Future Outlook
While Toffoli was the main focus, the hosts emphasized that Mike Grier is not done building the roster.
- “Big Money Mike”: Grier earned the nickname for his aggressive day-one approach, showing he has the green light to use the team’s available cap space.
- Playoff Bubble Projections: Despite the additions, the hosts remain realistic, targeting the 2025-26 season as the year the Sharks could truly become a “playoff bubble” team.
